Chris Schmalz profile image

By Chris Schmalz

Chris has lived in the Idaho Falls area for over 40 years and has been helping sellers and buyers realize the American dream and build wealth through real estate for over 20 years.

Get the Most from Your Home Sale. Start with a casual chat to craft a plan as unique as your home’s story. Book a Call

Few things unsettle a home sale faster than a buyer's inspector turning up something the seller never knew about. It’s one of the most common reasons a deal gets renegotiated, and sometimes the reason it falls apart altogether.

So when you’re preparing to list, and someone suggests hiring your own inspector before the home reaches the market, the instinct makes sense. Find out what’s wrong before a buyer does.

Most of the time, that instinct works for sellers. Still, experienced agents don’t recommend it to every seller, and it has less to do with the inspection itself than with what it leaves you knowing.

What a pre-inspection actually is. A pre-listing inspection is simply a home inspection you order and pay for yourself before listing, rather than waiting for the buyer to order theirs. It’s the same walkthrough, it covers the same major systems, and it produces the same written report.

The only differences are timing and who reads the findings first, which, in this case, is you.

When it helps, it really helps. Learning about issues on your own schedule means you can address them calmly instead of scrambling under a contract deadline while a nervous buyer watches. You can gather your own repair quotes instead of responding to a buyer’s inflated estimate, and you can price the home realistically because you know its condition.

The greatest benefit is fewer surprises later, which is often what preserves the deal. It builds trust, too. The case is strongest when a home is older, has deferred maintenance, or you already suspect something is wrong with a major system.

The disclosure catch. In most states, once you know about a material defect, something that affects the home’s value or safety, you generally must disclose it to buyers. Disclosure is triggered by what you know, and a pre-inspection is, in effect, a machine for creating knowledge.

That means a single report can hand you a list of items you now have to put in writing, whether or not you repair them. You can’t unknow what the inspector tells you.

Because disclosure laws vary considerably from state to state, what counts as a defect, and what you owe buyers, depends on where you live.

“Disclosure is triggered by what you know, and a pre-inspection is a machine for creating knowledge.”

Focus on what buyers will request. It’s natural to assume you’ll simply fix whatever the report finds. Instead, I counsel my sellers on what a buyer is most likely to request, and we focus on those items: the roof, the HVAC system, electrical, plumbing, and anything that could present a safety or structural concern.

Alternatively, we can price the home to reflect those important repairs.

Three factors that decide it. Ultimately, the decision comes down to three things: your home’s age and condition, your local disclosure rules, and how much uncertainty you’re comfortable carrying into a sale.

Lean toward a pre-inspection if your home is older, you’ve deferred maintenance, or you’d rather control surprises than be ambushed by them. It becomes more of a judgment call when the home is newer or well maintained, or when you’re selling in a hot market where buyers sometimes waive inspections anyway.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and it’s much easier to decide with someone who knows both your home and your market.

If you’re thinking about selling in Southeast Idaho and you’re not sure whether a pre-inspection is right for your home, don’t guess. Thinking through your home’s condition, our local rules, and your goals is exactly what I can help you with, so you can make the call that fits. I’m Chris Schmalz with the Chris Schmalz Real Estate Group: Where moves are made simple, and life is made Better. Call or text me at 208-242-4313, email me at chris@realestate-idahofalls.com, or visit blog.realestate-idahofalls.com. Reach out anytime, and let’s figure out the smartest way to get your home sold.

  • Get the Most from Your Home Sale. Start with a casual chat to craft a plan as unique as your home’s story. Book a Call

  • Discover Your Home’s True Value. Don’t trust a Zestimate. Get a personalized home valuation directly from Chris Schmalz. Get Estimate

  • Free Real Estate Newsletter. Get our latest Q&A, insights, and market updates to make smarter decisions. Subscribe Now